Is Emery A Better Coach Than Wenger?
My Naija peeps I hail una!
So yet another banter performance by our dear club. We struggled against a club that’s presently 20th on the league table. Arsenal in recent years have been so generous, reviving the careers of teams and players that are struggling for form - Southampton, Watford, Benteke, you name it. Anytime a match is underway and the spirits of fans are so high I become weary because in most cases we underperform.
So the golden questions all fans need to answer - Is Emery a better coach than Wenger? Is the team improved under Emery? Are those frailties we have lived with over the years still there?
I must say that I was really for Wenger out because I felt he had overstayed his welcome and performances were on a downward trajectory. I really wish for Emery to be successful. I really want him to be named amongst those with the Midas touch like Klopp, Mourinho, Conte etc. Even when he was criticized last season I defended him saying he had no good players and he needed time. But this is the tipping point and I must blatantly say that Emery has not improved this team.
Firstly the team after over a year still has no identity. No style of play, no specific formation, no regular starting 11 - its weird. Even though I’m not a fan I can tell you the style and starting 11 of City, Liverpool, Sp**rs, Chelsea.You need a set of players to play together regularly to form a chemistry unless the team becomes unstable. Initially, we embraced this “unpredictability” as a good thing since his predecessor was the exact opposite. However, the uncertainty has taken a toll on the players as rumors circulating within Colney is that the instructions given by the coach leave them confused (familiar?). Besides, when Emery says our philosophy is to “play from the back”, it is very vague and has proven to be ineffective. For example against Liverpool at Anfield, Klopp in the pre-match conference made this known and the match proved how ineffective it was. Unless you have a La Masia trained coach or players that are very technical on the ball, playing from the back makes no sense because we are not presently a passing team. So opponents will press and you will make a mistake.
Secondly, we now find it difficult to dominate matches. Against Watford we received a whooping 30 shots on goals against us! A struggling team that are 20th position! In the UEL final last season we were so lack lustre. We may not be a City, PSG or Barca but I think we have enough players to make us look more interesting than we are - Auba, Laca, Pepe, Ozil, Ceballos, Guendouzi, Torreira, Willock. I think with these crop of players we should be getting something more dominating. But it appears the coach is always too cautious, conservative, putting on the handbrakes unnecessarily. The football dey too one kind - patch patch. No pattern, no rhythm.
Thirdly, our defense has not improved. Yes I agree that Mustafi and Xhaka errors have made it so but from another perspective our tactics may be putting them under more pressure even though they aren’t good defenders. From Sokratis error, we see that the confusion came from trying to "play from the back" against an opponent with a high press. We have too many defensive errors its alarming! Do you know that we concede a penalty almost every match? In fact, for any big match we are going to play against any top European team, I’m almost certain we must concede a penalty. I know this was happening under Wenger but its now worse. I think the reason is that we don’t dominate the game and that puts us under pressure in addition to what playing from the back does. Note that David Luiz even though he's not so good as a defender conceded as much penalties in his entire Chelsea career as he's done playing only 4 matches for Arsenal - shows you the problem is from our culture.
Finally team selection. He always makes weird selections, putting square pegs in round holes. Initially his subs were brilliant and we were glad that Wenger wasn’t doing that but I don’t understand what happened eventually. For example a defensive pair of Chambers and Sokratis was very solid in our opening match but what happened to that subsequently? Why remove Xhaka against Brighton last season when it seemed like a goal was coming? Why didn’t he put Nketiah earlier against Brighton when he knew we needed a goal?
There was a time that a coach could never be sacked in that club irrespective of the performances; but with the new club structure would that happen? Would Edu as Director of Football watch as our attacking traditions as a club deteriorate? With what we are seeing I don’t think we can make top 4 which is Emery’s scorecard.
It would be an insult to compare Arsene to this man.

Comments
Post a Comment